We're northeast transplants and have tried most of the pizza in Salem in the few months we've lived here. Straight From New York is by far the closest to NY/NJ pizza. We ordered slices. Yes they needed to be reheated, and it did them no harm. The crust was crispy, yet pliable. The ingredients were hot, yet not inferno hot, thus no blistered mouth. The toppings (meat lovers and veggie) we're fresh, very tasty, and plentiful.
SF
Straight from New York Pizza
Restaurants Member since 2021
Call (503) 361-1234
4.3 / 5
4.3 from 300 reviews on Google
Do you own or manage Straight from New York Pizza?
Claim This Profile 2918 Commercial St SE, Salem, OR 97302 (503) 361-1234
Reputation
What people are saying
This pizza is so worth the wait or delivered. We had a pepperoni and all meat pizza. The smoked ham was amazing. Slices fold in half nicely and disappear quickly.
If u like a new York style pie...this is as close as it gets in Salem. Tangy sauce. Great toppings. Thin crust with a fat yeasty edge. You have to fold it....big slices! They bake them at very high temps and fast...which is the right way to do it.
Reviews posted on Google.