I was heading to a trail race and needed a bagel to prep for the race. I'm from PA and found them online. Headed over and when I saw the pot in the back where they boiled the bagels I knew I was getting a legit bagel. It was great, the coffee was too, but the customer service was great at a time when most businesses give zero customer service. They were friendly and talkative and I appreciate some level of customer service and will pay extra for it. Prices were reasonable and the bagel was great. BTW, I'm the guy that told you about Astoria Bagel in Queens, NY and your product was the equal of Astoria Bagel. The next time I'm in town, I'll be here every morning.
Photo: New Garden Bagel Co. / Google
New Garden Bagel Co.
Bagel Shops Member since 2026
Based on 541 reviews from Google. Read reviews
Do you own or manage New Garden Bagel Co.?
Claim This ProfileFeatured Reviews
The atmosphere is cozy and friendly. It’s bustling because it’s amazing! There’s very limited seating – literally the ONLY reason I took away one star. However, because they’re so efficient, most people seem to take their meals to-go and tables are often available. I purchased a hazelnut and French vanilla latte and a sesame seed bagel with jalapeño spread. (Insert chef’s kiss 👩🍳) This was my second visit and look forward to my next!
We read the reviews that suggested preordering online, which was easy to do. Our order was ready right about when we arrived. Our bagels were made accurately, fresh, and served warm. They tasted great and lots of choices to choose from. The mocha latte made with homeland creamery chocolate milk was also very good. We look forward to coming here again.