My fiancé went in to get an engagement ring just days before proposing, and the team treated him like family. When I needed it resized, they showed me the same kindness and care, making sure I felt valued throughout the entire process. Their attention to detail and customer service are unmatched. If you're looking for a jeweler who truly cares, this is the place to go!
Neustaedter's Fine Jewelers
Jewelry Stores Member since 2025
5.0 from 267 reviews on Google
Do you own or manage Neustaedter's Fine Jewelers?
Claim This ProfileFeatured Reviews
Amazing place! Helped me pick out several great beautiful gifts for my girlfriend’s birthday. Helped me out with everything. Extremely kind patient and knowledgeable staff! Helped me out with repairing my pendant with ease as well as ordering a new necklace that I liked. They have an easy to see catalog of things they can get ordered for the store. Absolutely pleased massive help
I brought in an earring that needed repair requiring replacement of a small diamond and a new stud. I asked if I could replace both studs with threaded ones, and was pleasantly surprised to know this was no problem! I was able to retrieve them in less than two weeks, and was very pleased with the results. Anna was awesome to deal with, also got back to me on another piece I was interested in. Great family owned jewelry store!
Reviews posted on Google.