Ordered a cake for my bday and when I went to pick it up the cake's colors did not match what I asked for. After explaining this, the team lead for today graciously redid the entire top layer (it was a double doozie) and even made the rainbow and text bigger so the icing covered more of the cookie. Super grateful to that team lead, totally wish I could have grabbed his name. Thank you for saving my bday!
Great American Cookies
Bakeries Member since 2023
4.2 from 77 reviews on Google
Do you own or manage Great American Cookies?
Claim This ProfileWhat people are saying
Ordered 2 separate cookie cakes and they turned out great. However, the second one seemed more thin than usual. My only suggestion to the company would be to get bags for the cookie cakes. It would be really helpful when carrying the cake to the car in the rain and carrying it around.
Stopped in the mall for shoes tonight and walked by the cookies. Decided to try a few to snack on and OMG! We got the pecan, the chocolate fudge, and a peanut butter and WOW! Each on was better than the last. It is so hard to pick a favorite!You nailed the flavors! The chocolate is all the best things you would want in a fudge brownie flavor. The peanut butter is better than eating pb off the spoon. And the pecan! It tastes just like pecan pie in cookie form. You now have a new fan!
Reviews posted on Google.