Last night we stopped by DeCarli Restaurant hoping for dinner..we did not have a reservation but the Hostess was lovely and we waited over an hour to be seated. It had been a stressful day and the most appealing item on the menu for me was the NY Steak. At $48.00 I decided that a steak with a side dish of chantrelle mushrooms was just what I needed. The server was lovely and when my plate arrived it appeared very inviting. Unfortunately my "medium rare" steak was on the far side of Medium and I had to actually saw through it to cut. There was just a very slight pink in the center and even the server agreed it was not what I had asked for. Because we were tired and had waited a long time I proceeded to eat what I could but really felt like an overcooked steak was over the top for a $48.00 entree. My daughter ordered their short ribs which is her favorite and when she left at least half on the plate I asked her why and she said that they too were quite dry. Very unusual! At first I was not going to write a review but after we speculated that perhaps the kitchen was cutting back on the quality of the beef due to the high prices of beef I decided to at least let people know that not everyones experience is perfect. The Butterscotch buddino was delicious!
Showing all 5 reviews
Amazing food. The only thing better was the service. They went out of their way to make our meal unforgettable.
Quite honestly, there are not enough stars available in the reviews to fully capture the outstanding experience that is decarli. We were first greeted by a wonderful hostess, followed by an amazing server named Bonnie. Bonnie was so personable, knowledgeable, attentive, and kind. Everyone on staff was very professional and friendly. The atmosphere is very inviting with candles, an eye catching chandelier, as well as beautifully decorated wall art. This restaurant reminded us of the fantastic modern Italian cuisine we loved in our home city of New York City. We will be back often and look forward to trying more dishes on the menu rotation of exceptional food offered here. Tonight it was the lasagna, cavatelli, Caesar salad, and margherita pizza that we selected for our first visit here. Every bite was simply delectable. The desserts we tried were the s’mores and caramel cheesecake-absolutely next level flavor and presentation. Also, thank you for providing such an incredible experience for my brother’s birthday! Though we came for a special occasion, we plan to be back consistently. Decarli, you are a true treasure! We look forward to returning soon! Thank you so much!
Took a party of 21 (high schoolers & chaperones) to DeCarli's last night for a Spring Formal dinner. From planning and booking communications to arrival, atmosphere, service, meal, special diets, timing, and departure, Jana and staff at DeCarli made our night simply magical. Jana helped us create a menu that would be sophisticated and yet every teenager went away raving. (Some may have lamented that they had to have the self-control to not lick their plates...) the staff made sure this large table was well taken care of throughout, everyone communicated with me about timing (we had a show to make downtown). The food was beautifully presented & sublimely delicious. The atmosphere has such a great balance of aesthetics, proper volume for conversations, not over-crowded & yet filled with patrons.
The best overall meal, experience and atmosphere I've seen in a long time at a restaraunt. From the delicious Oysters to the incredible Short Ribs, to the delectable Salted Caramel Cheesecake. The pasta that comes with the Short Ribs was outstanding! The entire meal was amazing and I would strongly recommend giving this restaurant a look if you love ribs!
You’ve reached the end of 5 reviews.