Skip to main content

Contact Oregon Mutual Insurance

Have a question or want to work together? We'd love to hear from you.

Add more details (optional)
Oregon Mutual Insurance

3.0 162 reviews on Google, WhirLocal, Facebook and Yelp

Homeowners flood insurance claim

Our experience with Sarah McDonough in making our homeowners claim was horrible. It started with her trying to talk me out of making a claim in the first place, threatening that our rates would go up and that insurance is made for catastrophic events. We decided to go ahead anyway since this seemed catastrophic enough to us, and thought this was exactly what homeowners insurance was for. This was our first time ever making a claim after owning a home for over 30 years. Basically she was rude every time I talked to her and made me feel horrible after I submitted our receipts and paperwork for our flood insurance claim (due to a pipe bursting) She accused us of spending more money than she had basically ever seen before (we had to stay at a hotel while our floors were being refinished) and that we had spent way too much money on food. We could have spent much more but we truly just ate like we usually would, and we’re not extravagant. She kept questioning me over and over and after I would explain wouldn’t accept my answer and would question me again. We also stayed at two different hotels, one that was right next to my husbands work during the week and a different one on the weekend, and she made us feel like that was terrible to do (we weren’t aware that this would be a problem) I got to the end of our final conversation feeling horrible and am considering changing insurance companies because of my interactions with her. She also asked me how many times we usually eat dinner out in a week, and when I told her 2-3 times, she then deducted that amount from my receipts because she said we would have been eating out that many times anyway, so that the insurance wouldn’t pay for those meals. Sounded strange to me but by this time I was so upset I just said to do whatever. She did deduct those meals…still don’t know if that is typical? You’d think homeowners insurance is for those awful times in life when you need them (a part of our house flooding) but after dealing with Sarah I guess not…you pay in for 30 years and then are made to feel guilty for using it. So very disappointed. (By the end of the conversation she did finally realize how bad she had made me feel, and apologized saying she had not been feeling well the last few days. I’m a mom and accepted her apology, but what a disaster!)

JS
Jodi S. Posted on WhirLocal

More Reviews of Oregon Mutual Insurance

All Reviews
  • Nov 21, 2025

    5 Star Review by Deirdre E.

    Paid property taxes...yeahhhhh, done.

    Deirdre E. Read Review
  • May 20, 2024

    If you are completely new to forex options and bitcoin trading you can open an account with Mrs. Br

    If you are completely new to forex options and bitcoin trading you can open an account with Mrs. Brayan Patricia today on forex trade and earn more profit online trade. I started with $1000 and I made this $12,540 after 7 working days. I recommend anyone looking for a good online expert trader to contact her you can contact her on Em

    Gold W. Read Review
  • Feb 2, 2024

    Trading with a trusted account manager is what can make your dreams come through. For me Mrs. Graci

    Trading with a trusted account manager is what can make your dreams come through. For me Mrs. Gracie Maverick has the best trading strategies to win. I never believed on any post recommending online trading until I gave a try and the outcome was great for me. Making $6,750 out of $500 was a whole lot of profit for me. Thank me later

  • Nov 29, 2023

    5 Star Review by Dennis O.

    I had an older truck stolen. Oregon mutual stepped up to the plate and paid me $500.00 more than I thought it worth. The check came almost immediately. Buying Oregon mutual insurance is one of the best decisions I have ever made. Great job by all concerned.

    Dennis O. Read Review
  • Jul 21, 2023

    5 Star Review by Erick C.

    I am very satisfied with this company they are a blessing to my company Thank you for helping me grow and meet my goals. I recommend it

    Erick C. Read Review